← Back to ESG News Update

EU Lawmakers Move to Scrap Carbon Border Levy Emergency Brake

European Union lawmakers voted on September 15, 2026, to remove an emergency brake clause that would have allowed the bloc to temporarily su...


European Union lawmakers voted on September 15, 2026, to remove an emergency brake clause that would have allowed the bloc to temporarily suspend its carbon border levy if the measure caused imported goods to become significantly more expensive. The European Parliament instead backed a proposal to use revenue generated by the carbon border fee to compensate industries if the policy contributes to higher prices. The decision sets up negotiations with EU member states, which support retaining the suspension mechanism under certain circumstances. 

The carbon border levy, formally known as the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, or CBAM, came into force on January 1, 2026. It applies carbon costs to imports of products including steel and fertilisers, with the broader objective of preventing imported goods produced with higher carbon emissions from gaining an unfair price advantage over European products. EU industries already face carbon costs for their domestic emissions, so the border mechanism is intended to create a more comparable cost structure between imported and locally produced goods. 

The emergency brake became one of the most contested elements of the system. Under the proposal supported by EU member states, the bloc could suspend the carbon fee in certain circumstances, including situations where the price of a covered product increased by more than 50% over six months. The European Parliament's decision to remove that option means industries would instead receive compensation from carbon border levy revenues if the mechanism contributes to higher prices. 

The European Commission proposed the emergency brake last year following pressure from France to suspend the carbon fee on fertilisers. The issue was particularly sensitive because higher fertiliser costs can affect farmers' production expenses and ultimately food prices. France had argued for greater flexibility around the levy while still supporting the broader purpose of the EU's carbon border policy. 

The disagreement reflects a wider tension surrounding Europe's climate policies. The EU is attempting to raise the cost of carbon-intensive production while protecting European industries from competitors operating under less stringent environmental rules. At the same time, policymakers must consider how rapidly rising compliance and import costs could affect manufacturers, farmers and consumers. The emergency brake was designed as a potential safety valve, but some companies have warned that suspending the carbon levy could weaken incentives for low-carbon investment and undermine the domestic industries the mechanism was designed to protect. 

The Parliament's position therefore represents a stronger push to preserve the carbon cost rather than suspend it when prices rise. Under the proposed approach, revenue collected through the border levy could be redirected toward affected industries instead of temporarily removing the carbon charge from imports. This could provide companies with financial support while keeping the underlying carbon-pricing signal in place.

However, the Parliament's vote does not yet settle the matter. EU member states and the European Parliament will now negotiate the final rules. The negotiations are expected to cover both the emergency brake and other changes to the carbon border system, including an expansion to additional products such as washing machines and car parts. The outcome will determine how far the EU ultimately extends the mechanism and how much flexibility businesses receive when market conditions change. 

The vote also addressed concerns about potential loopholes in the treatment of aluminium imports. European lawmakers supported lowering the threshold for aluminium shipments subject to the carbon border fee from 50 metric tons to 5 metric tons. The change is intended to ensure the levy covers high-value, low-weight aluminium components used in products such as cars, doors and solar panels. 

Lawmakers also backed extending the carbon fee to post-consumer aluminium scrap. The material was not initially covered by the levy, raising concerns among European aluminium producers that foreign suppliers could increasingly use scrap to avoid the border charge and gain a price advantage over European manufacturers. Closing that gap could make the system more comprehensive, particularly as demand for lower-carbon aluminium and recycled materials increases. 

The European aluminium industry has warned that unresolved loopholes could place European manufacturers at a disadvantage. Paul Voss, director general of industry association European Aluminium, said companies would be severely exposed if the problems were not addressed. His comments underline the concern that an incomplete carbon border system could shift the competitive balance rather than simply encourage cleaner production. 

For exporters outside the European Union, the changes are also significant. Companies selling covered goods into the EU will increasingly have to account for the carbon intensity of their production as part of their access to the European market. This creates an incentive for manufacturers in exporting countries to improve emissions measurement, energy efficiency and production technologies, particularly where their products compete directly with European manufacturers.

The implications could extend beyond steel, fertilisers and aluminium as the EU considers bringing additional manufactured products into the system. The proposed inclusion of items such as washing machines and car parts suggests that the carbon border mechanism could increasingly affect complex global supply chains rather than only traditional heavy industries.

The September 15 vote therefore marks another stage in Europe's effort to integrate climate policy into international trade. The final rules will depend on negotiations between the European Parliament and EU member states, but the direction of travel is clear: lawmakers are seeking to tighten the carbon border system while addressing concerns about costs and competitiveness through industry compensation and tighter controls on potential loopholes.